Morning Thanks

Garrison Keillor once said we'd all be better off if we all started the day by giving thanks for just one thing. I'll try.

Monday, November 16, 2026

What I should have said


Just last Thursday, I was the moderator at a book discussion considering Abigail Gardner's memoir History of the Spirit Lake Massacre and the Captivity of Miss Abbie Gardner, a book chosen by area librarians for a program they've created, "One Book, One Sioux County."

Abbie Gardner's story is far-and-away the most well-known narrative of the region's Native sagas. It was a massacre that took the lives of as many as 38 white pioneers who had only begun to settle the northwest corner of Iowa. It's an ugly story. For years, locals thought of Inkaduta as a Satanic figure, guiltly as he and his band was of cold-blooded murder.

In recent years, more in-depth research determined that Inkpaduta was himself a victim of injustice that absolved a white murderer of his own brother and family. That story does not free Inkpaduta of what he and his band of Santee Sioux did on the banks of Lake Okoboji.

It was my job to shape the discussion and create helpful discussion from the two real experts on the story. It wasn't a difficult job--the respondents knew the story inside and out. I think it went well, save for one tragic weakness.

 If you're going to spend much time with the story, you have to be ready to take in long and painful incidents without a joyful ending. Just as it's difficult to say anything positive about the 1862 Dakota War in Minnesota, it's hard to come out smiling from any discussion of the Spirit Lake Massacre just a few years previous. There was simply no reason for the massacre, even a general one--white settlers shouldn't have homesteaded on land that had belonged to indiginous residents.

And I was the moderator. If anyone was going to say anything positive about the story, it would have to be me.

It took me a day or two after last week's election to come up with something good to say. Thus, the event didn't end with something positive--Inkpaduta, who was never punished for the massacre, may have had cause, but that cause was not a liscense to murder men, women, and children.

What can be said? This, I think. Here's the good news.

In last Tuesday's election, four Native women were elected to office--four! Left to right (above), they include Tina Abrams, elected president of the Seneca Nation, the first woman to hold that position; Peggy Flanagan (White Earth Nation Ojibwe), elected to the U.S. Senate from Minnesota, the first Native American woman elected to the Senate; Deb Haaland (Laguna Pueblo), elected Governor of New Mexico and the first Native American woman elected governor of a U.S. state; and Tina Abrams, elected president of the Seneca Nation, the first woman to hold that position.

I wish I'd said it then, but at least I'm telling you now. Unless you're total MAGA, you can't help but be thrilled.

No comments: