Denouement isn't exactly just an English teacher's word. It looks and feels and is French in origin, but it refers to the story's answer to this question: "so what?" What effect did the story have on a kid named Gary, on his life.
I had options--it ruined it, is one. Another would be that it retooled him into the angel he never was. Options are many, most of them rise from a place on a continuum that stretches between poles in just about everyone's life--on one end profound effects, and on the other, minimal.
That Gary is telling the story does more than suggest that his father's haymow lesson has most certainly affected him. Would it prompt him to chase down Cassie and the child? I chose not to end the story with him claiming a son or daughter somewhere, but I wanted him to live the indictment his dad inflicted on him that dusty, hot day in Trillian's haymow.
Here's the denouement, the story's end. This is how the story ends:
*
Two years ago, I was divorced. I could give you a hundred reasons why, but none of them would be any good really. Anyway, I see my two kids on weekends, and I take them places, but you get tired of amusement parks and malls. So, I took them to the Dutch Festival in Easton yesterday, a half day’s ride north of Chicago, where we live.
Today I’m a teacher, special ed, in the schools there. My students are kids who don’t understand why it’s important to show up for work in the morning if you want to keep a job. And every year I get new ones, a new crop of sixteen-year-olds. This year I will too. And I wonder sometimes if I’d recognize that one of Cassie and me, the one I never saw. Maybe it was a girl.
Somewhere, I imagine, Cassandra Whoever-she’s-married-to is telling her story too, and it’s probably not at all the same.
But I couldn’t help thinking when I was sitting there yesterday on the curb, when I saw all those Dutch kids around town, all those preening girls and the boys with the developing shoulders, that somewhere someplace there’s this tall, gaunt, half-Dutch, sixteen-year-old, who could just as well be up in a stuffy haymow somewhere with my father, wearing out overalls by hoisting bales on his knee, his face sticky with sweat and chaff, and sometimes talking, sometimes talking.
*
I doubt my mom and dad ever read the story, but they might have. Here's what I would have liked to explain to them, parents who probably never understood what their son was up to by writing stories like "Paternity." Let the writer take the denouement apart:
Two years
ago, I was divorced [I wanted to suggest that his life hasn't been a bowl of cherries--is that because of what happened one summer on the lakeshore? I didn't care to have him somehow blame what happened with Cassie on her, but neither did I want him to simply forget it. This line deliberately suggests that he hasn't.] I could give you a hundred reasons why, but none of them
would be any good really. Anyway, I see my two kids on weekends, and I take
them places, but you get tired of amusement parks and malls. So, I took them to
the Dutch Festival in Easton yesterday, a half day’s ride north of Chicago,
where we live. [The phenomenon I noted one year at about the time our kids were approaching middle-school age, when we went to the Tulip Festival in Orange City: preening high school kids in tank tops in the warm, late spring.]
Today I’m
a teacher, special ed, in the schools there. [Making him a teacher was easy--I was one.] My students are kids who don’t
understand why it’s important to show up for work in the morning if you want to
keep a job [A friend of mine told me he did that--explaining that his students weren't a whole lot like the kids we knew growing up. What Gary doesn't say, but what he thinks is that his kids come from homes not so ship-shape as the home he grew up in]. And every year I get new ones, a new crop of sixteen-year-olds. This
year I will too. And I wonder sometimes if I’d recognize that one of Cassie and
me, the one I never saw. Maybe it was a girl. [I didn't want him obsessed, but that he was reminded every once in a while was, I thought, a good thing, a state of mind his father had accurately predicted.]
Somewhere,
I imagine, Cassandra Whoever-she’s-married-to is telling her story too, and
it’s probably not at all the same.
But I
couldn’t help thinking [it's something he remembers--"can't help it")when I was sitting there yesterday on the curb, when I
saw all those Dutch kids around town, all those preening girls and the boys
with the developing shoulders, that somewhere someplace there’s this tall,
gaunt, half-Dutch, sixteen-year-old, who could just as well be up in a stuffy
haymow somewhere with my father, wearing out overalls by hoisting bales on his
knee, his face sticky with sweat and chaff, and sometimes talking, sometimes
talking. [This is a tribute to his father. "Sometimes talking" suggests his father's silence is a feature he remembers and appreciates. It suggests, as imaginative literature always does, that Gary looks back at what happened one day in a lakeshore haymow as something he's drawn from the respect he had for his father.]
For now, let me lay out the roots of this story, roots that start, oddly enough with a darling pair of Dutch bunnies, the belted kind. Where they weren’t white, they were brown, not black. I bought them at a twice-a-year auction that, long ago, was the wildest and most fascinating auction in a six-county region. These bunnies were darling—or did I say that already? —and they were comfortable enough to tolerate each other as roomies. A boy and a girl, just like our kids, neat as neat can be.
Call me a bad parent, but I substituted doing the chores my children were supposed to do, daily, but had some trouble getting accomplished—feed the bunnies, keep their cage nice and clean, and play with them. Promise me that and, okay, Dad will buy a couple of those cuties. Most of those responsibilities got left to their father, but I started to love getting up in the morning and going out to the barn out back, as if I was some old retired farmer.
On Easter morning that year—sun bright and shiny in the sky—I went out to greet the day and found both bunnies gone. Initially, I worried about some kind of crime--they had been stolen! I looked around, all through the cage, which stood just outside the old barn, on the south side.
No bunnies.
It was Easter morning, a particularly religious holiday. If we had easter eggs, they came from our kids’ friends. Barbara and I weren’t big on Easter bunnies, save the wonderful twosome out back, who’d blessed our kids with brown and white fluff.
Quite quickly, I determined that telling the kids their bunnies were gone would be out of the question—I mean, my own soul felt bitten through. What might happen to them—and on Easter too?
So off we went to church. Barbara knew, but the two Schaap kids were innocent as lambs, more so.
All through the trumpets of Easter morning worship, all I could think about was those two bunnies, our kids’ bunnies, and how I would have to break the news that would have assuredly broken them. How would I say it? Where would we sit to tell them? They’d bawl, but would I?
Don’t ask me how the worship service went—I was parked in another zone.
When we got home, I snuck outside after telling Barb I was going to do one more search.
I did, and, amazingly, I found the two little sweeties balled up together beneath the neighbor’s lawn mower. I flipped the deck up and there they were, not fifty feet away, burrowed in the long grass beneath that old mower.
None of that is in the story, but, trust me, all of it is.
I was so incredibly relieved that it seemed impossible to believe. I had put myself into an emotional ringer because I had no idea how I would explain to my kids the deaths or absence of their two warm and snuggly bunnies.
I don’t know why, but that morning I happened to think about ending a pregnancy, about abortion, about what it was. And what I ran into was a contrast my mind couldn’t help but project. For pity’s sake, a rabbit left me at wits end, an animal--a terribly cute pair of them, but not a creature blessed with a soul. Their mysterious absence flat-out ruined my Easter morning.
Now let me be clear. I’m not a huge anti-abortion kind of guy. Politically, I’m most often on the progressive side. I’ve long ago had my fill of hyper-Christians who can’t or won’t take the time to empathize with those (especially women) who would just as soon not let the state tell them what to do with their bodies.
I’m not a fierce anti-abortion guy, but the comparison was too evident in my own life: I was long gone from the Easter worship that morning because my mind, my heart, and my soul were consumed by the startling absence of two rabbits.
There’s a story here, I told myself, something about taking human life more seriously. That’s something this whole arrangement of Easter morning events had made clear.
And then there was this. We’d heard the story from friends of ours, how a young lady somewhat prematurely pregnant with child had told her parents that it wasn’t that big of a deal—“it’ll all be over by volleyball.”
There’s something so patently ridiculous, so insanely juvenile, about that remark—and something totally childlike in its precious innocence. I gave the story to a football player.
I’ve never written a story that’s more "pro-life" than "Paternity." I doubt they ever knew.